Simply Energy’s RACV Deal is Better Than Tango’s for Big Electricity Users

This is a review of the Simply Energy Electricity Deal for RACV members with a comparison to Tango Energy

Previously when we looked at the easy to follow pricing from Tango, it appeared Tango had the best pricing possible for customers on the Powercor network in Victoria.  The pricing analysis, including looking at the Victorian Energy Compare site, showed that Tango’s electricity deal was one of the most competitive if not the cheapest.

As most retail customers pay GST, all prices mentioned include GST to hopefully provide the most meaningful numbers.

Recently Simply Energy has increased it’s discount on Electricity supply for RACV members from 40% to 45%.  The headline discount numbers do not have much meaning without baseline line usage prices in cents/kWh to apply the discount to.

Unfortunately it appears the base usage rates from Simply Energy have increased from 29.106c/kWh in June 2018 to 31.768c/kWh more recently.  The net effect (of the smoke and mirrors from the marketing department) is usage costs have not changed at all.  Net usage costs went from from 17.464c/kWh to 17.472c/kWh which is in fact an increase but not an increase worth talking about.

What has changed since June 2018 from Simply Energy is the supply costs on the Powercor network which went from $1.2765/day to $1.2089/day  or a decrease of 6.76c per day or $24.67 per year.

What is the daily supply charge of Tango Vs Simply Energy?

Most if not all electricity retailers do not apply discounts to the daily supply charge.  The supply charge is depends on the network distributor.  Regional areas tend to have higher supply charges when compared to city areas.  Generally there is more infrastructure, power lines and transformers, required to service the longer distances in regional areas and they are also servicing less people.

For example Simply Energy’s daily supply rates for the Citipower area in and around Melbourne are $1.09582 vs $1.2089 for the Powercor area of Western Victoria being a 10% increase for the regional area.

Tango’s daily supply charge as at 12 June 2018 on the Powercor network is the lowest at $1.056 compared to Simply Energy’s daily supply charge of $1.2089 – a difference of 0.1529c per day or $55.81 per year.

What is the usage price of Tango vs Simply Energy after discounts?

When it comes down to the usage price in cents per kWh on the single rate pricing plans (also called the Peak Only rate) Simply Energy’s rate is $0.1747c per kWh and Tango’s is $0.1863c per kWh.

Tango has a lower daily supply (14% lower) and a higher usage price (7% higher per kWh usage price).  Or put another way Simply Energy has a higher daily supply charge and a lower usage price.

Overall Tango is cheaper up to around 13kWh usage per day.  13kWh would represent moderate usage for a 4 bedroom household.

Simply Energy’s lower per kWh usage costs create more benefit as usage increases beyond 13kWh per day.  If air-conditioners are in heavy use regularly then Simply Energy’s 45% RACV discount plan would probably be of benefit over a year.

What are Tango’s Terms and Conditions like Compared to Simply Energy’s Terms and Conditions.

Connection and disconnection are cheaper with Tango.

You don’t have to be an RACV member to get Tango’s plan.  Simply Energy is attempting to make a competitive market offer look special by attaching more conditions, more conditions that might one day catch you out.  Whereas Tangos plan is more of a here it is, and there are no catches.

Tango has committed to keep rates fixed for 2 years, Simply Energy has stated they can change the rates when they like, this could mean prices could do down during the 2 year term also, but that scenario seems unlikely with a captive customer base.

Both Tango and Simply Energy offer a $50 first bill credit when you sign up.

 

Tango Offers Some of the Best Electricity Plans for Geelong and Western Victoria (via Powercor)

Tango’s Electricity Prices are one of the best in Geelong and Western Victoria

Tango offers one of the best electricity offers in Geelong when compared to AGL and Dodo electricity in the Powercor Western Regional Victoria area.

Unfortunately as at December 2018 Tango Energy does not have an online sign up, to sign up requires calling on 1800 010 648.  The time to sign up is only about 10 minutes and a good 5 minutes of that is the waste of time common sense blurb about the cooling off period and your rights.

Here we compare Tango’s prices with Simply Energy’s RACV plus plan.  Tango compares well with fewer conditions to be met (eg you don’t need to be an RACV member).

Tango electricity plans offer very transparent ‘zero discount’ pricing.  Which means instead of applying a headline discount rate to a usage rate to then get the real or net rate in c/kWh, Tango displays the net rate upfront with no ‘% discount’ to be applied.

If you sign up under the “Home eSelect” which includes paperless bills and direct debit payments, you will also get a $50 sign up credit www.tangoenergy.com/forhome

In the table below all prices include GST and are correct from Tango’s Energy Price Fact Sheet of 12 June 2018.   Any queries about the pricing please let us know at info@switchandsave.com.au.

The pricing is straight forward with a daily supply charge of $1.056 per day and a usage charge of 18.634c per kW.

Tango Electricity Price Comparison for Western Victoria

The Powercor western Victoria region includes Geelong, Colac, Mildura, Echuca, Cobram, Shepparton, Bendigo, Kyneton, Ballarat, Horsham and Warrambool.

Use this table to compare costs with your current electricity bill.

kWh usage per daySupply charge in cents per kWUsage charge in cents per kWSupply + Usage in cents per kW1 day cost $30 day cost $90 day cost $
5$0.210.18634$0.40$1.99$59.63$178.89
6$0.180.18634$0.36$2.17$65.22$195.66
7$0.150.18634$0.34$2.36$70.81$212.43
8$0.130.18634$0.32$2.55$76.40$229.20
9$0.120.18634$0.30$2.73$81.99$245.98
10$0.110.18634$0.29$2.92$87.58$262.75
11$0.100.18634$0.28$3.11$93.17$279.52
12$0.090.18634$0.27$3.29$98.76$296.29
13$0.080.18634$0.27$3.48$104.35$313.06
14$0.080.18634$0.26$3.66$109.94$329.83
15$0.070.18634$0.26$3.85$115.53$346.60
16$0.070.18634$0.25$4.04$121.12$363.37
17$0.060.18634$0.25$4.22$126.71$380.14
18$0.060.18634$0.25$4.41$132.30$396.91
19$0.060.18634$0.24$4.60$137.89$413.68
20$0.050.18634$0.24$4.78$143.48$430.45
21$0.050.18634$0.24$4.97$149.07$447.22
22$0.050.18634$0.23$5.16$154.66$463.99
23$0.050.18634$0.23$5.34$160.25$480.76
24$0.040.18634$0.23$5.53$165.84$497.53
25$0.040.18634$0.23$5.71$171.44$514.31

Who owns Tango Energy?

Tango Energy is based in Geelong, Victoria and is the retail arm of Pacific Hydro.   Pacific Hydro is a wind and hydro renewable energy provider based in Melbourne, Victoria.

Contact details for Tango Energy

Email support@tangoenergy.com or phone 1800 010 648.

What distributors and areas does Tango Energy cover?

Tango covers Victorian and South Australian gas and electricity customers via several distributors including Ausnet (eastern regional Victoria), Citipower (CBD and Inner suburbs of Melbourne), Jemena (North West Melbourne), Powercor – Western Regional Victoria, United Energy – South Eastern Melbourne ans Mornington Penisnsuala.

 

 

Simply Energy Electricity and Gas Deal Review for RACV Members June 2017

 

The analysis below has been updated with the Simply RACV Plus deal which offers 45% off electricity since 26 September 2018.

 

To help compare electricity and gas suppliers we are doing common sense deal reviews to try and decipher the marketing blurb into what it might mean for your actual electricity and gas bills.

Below is one deal review from Simply Energy for RACV members

Headline points of the deal

  • $50 online credit (The online part means it doesn’t apply if you call them to sign up and it’s split in half $25 credit for electricity and $25 credit for gas)
  • 40% off electricity usage charges – usage charges are not shown, so 40% off what number we don’t know
  • 25% off gas charges – again usage charges are not shown, so 25% off what number is unknown.
  • You must pay on time to get the discount, if you don’t pay on time I suppose the assumption is the discounts are removed altogether?
  • The discount does not apply to supply or other charges.
  • 24 month contract or ‘benefit period’ with no exit fees, so the contract is a lock in for them not you?  I’m sure they can change rates mid-contract term if they like, if you do want to leave before the end of 24 months you can free of charge.  So the ‘term’ is a hangover from legal contracts requiring a term, in this context, it seems pretty meaningless.

Example Electricity costs per day with Simply Energy

kWh usage per daySupply charge in cents per kWUsage charge in cents per kWSupply + Usage in cents per kWPer day cost $30 day cost $90 day cost $40% discount '$ savings' over 90 days
1012.76517.46430.2293.0290.69272.06104.78
158.5117.46425.9743.9116.88350.64157.17
206.38317.46423.8464.77143.08429.23209.56
255.10617.46422.575.64169.27507.82261.95

From the advertisements, you are sent to SimplyEnergy.com.au/RACV where you are asked for your name RACV member number before you can proceed (hopefully to find out the actual usage charges) then you are asked for your postcode.

If you are on a ‘flexible pricing tarriff’ then you have to call to get rates, they won’t show the rates online.  Flexible pricing tariff meaning peak, shoulder, and off-peak depending on the time of day when electricity is used.

Then you have to enter your name, email, address, date of birth and answer 4 questions about your address and if you own the property

Next questions are how you would like to pay.

I still haven’t seen the actual price yet!  So I found the Simply Energy compare plans link in the footer of the page – phew!

I get to the base rates which are below.  The base rates also refer to Market Contract Terms and Conditions which is a 33 page booklet.  There is no mention of $ or kWh in the terms and conditions.  You can terminate the contract by giving 20 business days’ notice. However, after the contract ends they will continue to sell you energy on the same terms until you enter into a new contract with them or transfer to another retailer

I don’t think the peak and off peak is very attractive unless you work at night and sleep during the day.

Using the single rate meter rates peak at 29.106c/kWh discounted 40% is 17.464c/kWh plus supply charge of $1.2765 (all inc GST).

Standardising the supply charge across an average 15kW/h per day usage adds  8.51c per kW/h or 25.974c per kWh.

Simply Energy Electricity Rates (June 2017)

Single Rate meter (Peak)Unitexc. GSTInc. GST
Peak per quartercents/kWh26.460029.1060
Controlled Load 1 per quartercents/kWh18.400020.2400
Supply Charge
Supply Chargecents/day116.0500127.6550

 

Two Rate meter (Peak/Off Peak)
Peak (7am-11pm, Mon-Fri)cents/kWh34.050037.4550
Off Peak (11pm-7am, Mon-Fri & Sat-Sun)cents/kWh19.380021.3180
Supply Charge
Supply Chargecents/day116.0500127.6550

Simply Enery Gas Rates (June 2017)

Up to 30/09/2017:Unitexc. GSTInc. GST
First 6083 MJ per 2 monthscents/MJ2.19002.4090
Next 6084 MJ per 2 monthscents/MJ2.15002.3650
Next 73000 MJ per 2 monthscents/MJ1.46001.6060
Remainder per 2 monthscents/MJ1.42001.5620
Supply Charge
Supply Chargecents/day79.910087.9010

Electricity rates depend on the type of meter at your property. Please refer to the back of your bill for your meter type. These rates may change from time to time in accordance with our Market Contract Terms and Conditions.